Special Sections » Fall Guide

Only the movies you want to see


As I was thinking about how to structure this piece on the films of autumn, I became hung up on the notion of film criticism versus movie reviewing. Film criticism is an art that seems to require a thorough steeping in film history, astute reasoning, an extremely keen eye, and the ability to concisely convey your thoughts using clever word-type thingies. This paper has a film critic, and it ain't me.

I'm a movie reviewer, which isn't so much an art as it is a scam, and I feel semi-guilty. Sure, I've seen more than my share of flicks, having worked on the exhibition side of the business called show for a number of years, but my opinion is no more valid than yours and you really shouldn't listen to me.

Still reading? Fine. This fall movie preview will consist solely of the films that I am most looking forward to and why, and I am so drunk on self-importance right now that I've decided to set this article to the tune of "Super Freak," in homage to the late Rick James. It's also in chronological order in case you don't want to sing along.

Please note that I so don't like Jude Law, and despite the fact that he has a handful of films coming out before the end of the year, I am only mentioning him to let you know I won't be mentioning him.

Infernal Affairs

John Woo didn't corner the market on Hong Kong shoot-em-ups with maudlin music and simple dialogue. One cop infiltrates a gang while another cop sits snugly in the gang leader's pocket as both sides try to root out the mole. See it before Scorsese's remake comes out next year so you can outsnob your chums with comparisons between the two films. (Release: September 17, limited)

Silver City

I love John Sayles but haven't been too thrilled with him lately (perhaps we're dating). Hopefully we can kiss and make up as a result of his look at the state of our country. Chris Cooper plays a Dubya-type politician who may be connected with the dead body found on the set of his TV ad. Good gravy, it sounds like Lone Star. Yay! (Release: September 17, limited)

The Motorcycle Diaries

Gael Garcia Bernal (Y Tu Mamá También) portrays Che Guevara in Walter Salles' adaptation of Che's memoirs about the revolutionary's travels through Latin America as a young man. The kids wear the shirt, and now they might even learn why. (Release: September 24, limited)

I Heart Huckabees

True story: I was working at a movie theatre that was showing David O. Russell's Spanking the Monkey when a little old lady plunked her money down and requested, "One Spanking, please." His new comedy stars Dustin Hoffman and Lily Tomlin as a married couple who help people with their existential crises. The cast also features Jason Schwartzman, Mark Wahlberg, and He Who Shall Not Be Mentioned. (Release: October 1, limited)


This Sundance award-winning documentary has gotten a ton of buzz and looks at the complicated relationship between Courtney Taylor of the Dandy Warhols and Anton Newcombe from the Brian Jonestown Massacre. (Release: October 1, limited)

Stage Beauty

Billy Crudup left his pregnant girlfriend for Claire Danes after they shot this period love story set amidst the footlights. It had better be good. (Release: October 8, limited)

Vera Drake

Master filmmaker Mike Leigh's latest features British character actress Imelda Staunton in an Oscar-bait performance about a woman, devoted to her family and friends, who performs abortions on the side in 1950s England. (Release: October 8, limited)

Shall We Dance?

I know, I know --- I'm sick of Jennifer Lopez, too. But if you've seen the Japanese original about a dance instructor who inspires a milquetoast, you know that the source material is so good that it should be tough to screw up. And I am the most naïve optimist. (Release: October 15)

Team America: World Police

The South Park creators jettison the construction paper in favor of marionettes who fight terrorism via musical numbers and swearing. Why not? Something's bound to work. (Release: October 15)


Alexander Payne follows up About Schmidt with a road-trip movie about two guys (Paul Giamatti and the underused Thomas Haden Church) on a week-long wine-tasting jaunt spent contemplating life's bigger questions. (Release: October 20)


Jamie Bell, aka Billy Elliot, stars for co-producer Terrence Malick and director David Gordon Green (George Washington, All the Real Girls) in this Southern Gothic coming-of-age tale about two brothers who run away from home to escape their greedy, ex-con uncle. Green's usual cinematographer Tim Orr returns, and the results are gorgeous. (Release: October 29, limited)

It's All About Love

Finally, something else from Denmark's Thomas Vinterberg, who made the first (and possibly the best) Dogme 95 film, The Celebration (recently released on DVD, incidentally). It reunites U-Turn's Claire Danes, Joaquin Phoenix, and Sean Penn in a futuristic thriller about a divorce that's not going as planned. (Release: October 29, limited)

Callas Forever

To my eyes, France's Fanny Ardant is the most beautiful woman in the world. She plays opera singer Maria Callas for director Franco Zeffirelli in this fictional look at the last few months of the diva's life. (Release: November 5, limited)

The Incredibles

If the trailers are any indication, Pixar Studios will extend their winning streak with this chunk of animation about a family of retired superheroes called back into action. It features the voices of Craig T. Nelson, Holly Hunter, Samuel L. Jackson, and Jason Lee, and it's by the director of The Iron Giant! (Release: November 5)

Finding Neverland

The always-welcome Johnny Depp portrays Scottish author J.M. Barrie. Marc Forster (Monster's Ball) looks at Barrie's relationship with a widow (Kate Winslet) and her four sons, who inspired Barrie's masterpiece, Peter Pan. Hmm, maybe Depp's Oscar movie? (Release: November 12, limited)

Bridget Jones: The Edge of Reason

Renee Zellweger revisits her Oscar-nominated role as Bridget Jones in this sequel to the totally delightful --- yet still slightly edgy --- Bridget Jones's Diary. Only problem is, the novel on which this film is based was rather awful. Hopefully they can work some Bridges of Madison County-type magic. (Release: November 19)

Bad Education

Writer-director Pedro Almodóvar is back with this bit of noir about a transvestite (the suddenly ubiquitous Gael Garcia Bernal) who reunites with an old friend in the 1980s as he tries to cope with his childhood molestation by a priest. (Release: November 19, limited)

National Treasure

Producer Jerry Bruckheimer and Nicolas Cage together again? In an action flick that sounds like The DaVinci Code with an American slant? If anyone needs me, I'll be in line. (Release: November 19)

Ocean's Twelve

Do we really need this sequel? Probably not. But Ocean's Eleven was a cash cow full of gorgeous people having too much fun, and this heist goes down in Italy with the main 11 characters from the first film (Clooney, Pitt, Roberts, et al.). If it ain't broke. (Release: December 10)

The Life Aquatic

The final entry in 2004's Fall Movie Preview is the movie about which I am most excited. Director Wes Anderson (Bottle Rocket, Rushmore, The Royal Tenenbaums) can do no wrong in my book, and his latest stars the great Bill Murray as an oceanographer on the trail of the shark that ate his partner. Also starring Cate Blanchett, Angelica Huston, and Owen Wilson, who for the first time does not share screenwriting credit on a Wes Anderson film. Anderson co-wrote Aquatic with Noah Baumbach, a clever filmmaker in his own right (Kicking and Screaming). (Release: December 10, limited)

Remember that release dates, as well as my mind --- and maybe even about Jude Law --- are subject to change.

In This Guide...

  • Hitting the lecture circuit

    OK, all you nerds out there, it's time to get down to work. Stock your pencil boxes, pull out your literary anthologies, and check the batteries in your tape recorders: fall is bursting with enough lectures and literary events to make us all feel like we're back in school again.

  • Lack not music’s pleasures

    It may be years, decades, centuries, before the Olympics come to Rochester. While you're waiting, enjoy the abundant classical music Rochester offers every year, all year round.

  • Seeking the artful bounty

    Members of the Rochester Association of Art Dealers already inaugurated the new season; they strutted their stuff during Galleries Week, which started the second weekend of September. Most of their exhibits will remain up for several weeks, giving you plenty to see.

  • City’s choice: family theater

    Theater is not just for grownups. Besides the magical tradition of The Nutcracker, during the fall there are other performances around town for the family to enjoy.

  • Failure is so possible

    Fall arrives in Rochester with a flurry of colorful brochures announcing dance, music, and theater events. It's an exciting time of year for arts lovers --- authors start arriving, film festivals hit town, and art exhibitions open.

  • Putting on a good show

    It is, in my opinion, the best moment in the world: after the lights go down and before the show starts. Voices hush, bodies settle, and you wait.

  • Hear your live delights

    I figure since we got screwed out of summer we deserve a cool fall. And I'm not talking about the mercury either.

  • Searching for the Holy Grail (of fruit)

    The fall harvest season is one of my favorites, with cool nights and an almost endless variety of fruits and vegetables to sample, some more well-known than others. Lately, I have fallen in love with the heirloom tomato "Brandywine" --- which is not very red, is impossible to slice for the perfect sandwich, and has a thin skin unsuitable for shipping.

  • Fall Guide 2004

    Fall with grace It leads us into the grip of colder, darker winter, but fall is a gentle warden.